Theoretical Virtues in Science
Uncovering Reality through Theory

In-depth discussion of the value of scientific theories, bringing together and advancing current important debates in realism.

Samuel Schindler (Author)

9781108435031, Cambridge University Press

Paperback / softback, published 26 March 2020

261 pages, 10 b/w illus.
22.8 x 15.2 x 1.4 cm, 0.4 kg

'The book is clearly written, well-informed about both philosophy and history of science, and makes numerous incisive points. I would recommend this as an excellent guide to the literature, due to its clear overarching narrative thread, and the fact that Schindler is not afraid to point out various oddities and sources of confusion in the literature.' Darren Bradley, Metascience

What are the features of a good scientific theory? Samuel Schindler's book revisits this classical question in the philosophy of science and develops new answers to it. Theoretical virtues matter not only for choosing theories 'to work with', but also for what we are justified in believing: only if the theories we possess are good ones (qua virtues) can we be confident that our theories' claims about nature are actually correct. Recent debates have focussed rather narrowly on a theory's capacity to predict new phenomena successfully, but Schindler argues that the justification for this focus is thin. He discusses several other theory properties such as testability, accuracy, and consistency, and highlights the importance of simplicity and coherence. Using detailed historical case studies and careful philosophical analysis, Schindler challenges the received view of theoretical virtues and advances arguments for the view that science uncovers reality through theory.

Introduction
1. Theoretical virtues, truth, and the argument from simplicity
2. Pessimism, base rates, and the no-virtue-coincidence argument
3. Novel success and predictivism
4. Theoretical fertility without novel success
5. Ad hoc hypotheses and the argument from coherence
6. Virtues as confidence boosters and the argument from choice
7. Philosophy of science by historical means
Conclusion.

Subject Areas: Philosophy of science [PDA]