Samuel Johnson, the Ossian Fraud, and the Celtic Revival in Great Britain and Ireland

A detailed investigation of Johnson's response to the Ossian controversy, with a transcription of a rare anti-Ossian pamphlet he co-authored.

Thomas M. Curley (Author)

9780521407472, Cambridge University Press

Hardback, published 16 April 2009

348 pages
23.4 x 16 x 2 cm, 0.69 kg

"Thomas Curley has written a consummately Johnsonian book—one that takes up a topic about which Johnson spoke vehemently, that defends Johnson’s position, and that makes a rousing case for the equation of that position with unequivocal truth." -Matthew Wickman, Modern Philology Book Reviews

James Macpherson's famous hoax, publishing his own poems as the writings of the ancient Scots bard Ossian in the 1760s, remains fascinating to scholars as the most successful literary fraud in history. This study presents the fullest investigation of his deception to date, by looking at the controversy from the point of view of Samuel Johnson. Johnson's dispute with Macpherson was an argument with wide implications not only for literature, but for the emerging national identities of the British nations during the Celtic revival. Thomas M. Curley offers a wealth of genuinely new information, detailing as never before Johnson's involvement in the Ossian controversy, his insistence on truth-telling, and his interaction with others in the debate. The appendix reproduces a rare pamphlet against Ossian written with the assistance of Johnson himself. This book will be an important addition to knowledge about both the Ossian controversy and Samuel Johnson.

1. An introductory survey of scholarship on Ossian: why literary truth matters
2. James Macpherson's violation of literary truth
3. Johnson on truth, frauds, and folklore: in the company of Thomas Percy
4. Searching for truth in the Highlands: Macpherson throws down the gauntlet
5. Charles O'Conor and the Celtic Revival in Ireland
6. Johnson and the Irish: more opposition to Ossian
7. Johnson's last word on Ossian with William Shaw: a finale to controversy
Appendix: A Reply to Mr Clark (1782) by William Shaw in Association with Samuel Johnson
Bibliography
Index.

Subject Areas: Literary studies: c 1500 to c 1800 [DSBD], Literary studies: general [DSB], Literature & literary studies [D]