Is the Welfare State Justified?

Argues that contemporary political philosophy should converge in a rejection of central welfare state institutions.

Daniel Shapiro (Author)

9780521677936, Cambridge University Press

Paperback, published 9 July 2007

344 pages
22.6 x 15 x 2 cm, 0.458 kg

'This book is an important addition to the debate about the welfare state. [This book is an] extensive and quite remarkable survey of the social science literature on the operation of the relevant institutions and his integration of this material into arguments for and against the welfare state.' Eric Mack, Professor of Philosophy at Tulane University

In this book, Daniel Shapiro argues that the dominant positions in contemporary political philosophy - egalitarianism, positive rights theory, communitarianism, and many forms of liberalism - should converge in a rejection of central welfare state institutions. He examines how major welfare institutions, such as government-financed and -administered retirement pensions, national health insurance, and programs for the needy, actually work. Comparing them to compulsory private insurance and private charities, Shapiro argues that the dominant perspectives in political philosophy mistakenly think that their principles support the welfare state. Instead, egalitarians, positive rights theorists, communitarians, and liberals have misunderstood the implications of their own principles, which in fact support more market-based or libertarian institutional conclusions than they may realize. Shapiro's book is unique in its combination of political philosophy with social science. Its focus is not limited to any particular country; rather it examines welfare states in affluent democracies and their market alternatives.

1. Introduction
2. Central perspectives in political philosophy
3. Health insurance, part I
4. Health insurance, part II
5. Old-age or retirement pensions
6. Welfare or means-tested benefits, part I
7. Welfare or means-tested benefits, part II
8. Conclusion.

Subject Areas: Political science & theory [JPA], Social & political philosophy [HPS], Ethics & moral philosophy [HPQ], Philosophy [HP]