Culpable Carelessness
Recklessness and Negligence in the Criminal Law

A doctrinal and theoretical analysis of culpability for unjustified risk-taking in Anglo-American criminal law.

Findlay Stark (Author)

9781108465120, Cambridge University Press

Paperback / softback, published 6 December 2018

349 pages
23 x 15.2 x 1.8 cm, 0.45 kg

'Culpable Carelessness by Findlay Stark is a careful and considered contribution to the 'punishment for negligence' debate. As well as providing a comprehensive overview of the doctrinal and theoretical aspects of recklessness and negligence in the criminal law, it also offers novel insights for scholars already steeped in these debates. An additional methodological strength is that Stark takes seriously the connection between theory and law, offering useful potential jury instructions on recklessness and negligence.' Kimberly Kessler Ferzan, Modern Law Review

The question of when a person is culpable for taking an unjustified risk of harm has long been controversial in Anglo-American criminal law doctrine and theory. This survey of the approaches adopted in England and Wales, Canada, Australia, the United States, New Zealand and Scotland argues that they are converging, to differing extents, around a 'Standard Account' of culpable unjustified risk-taking. This Standard Account distinguishes between awareness-based culpability (recklessness) and inadvertence-based culpability (negligence) for unjustified risk-taking. With reference to criminal law theory and philosophical literature, the author argues that, when explained appropriately, the Standard Account is defensible and practical. Defending the Standard Account involves analysing in depth a number of controversial matters, including the meaning of advertence/awareness, the role of attitudes such as indifference in culpable risk-taking, and the question of whether negligence should be used in the criminal law.

1. Introduction
2. The doctrinal trend towards the Standard Account
3. Consistency in definition
4. From awareness to belief
5. Beyond belief: knowledge and awareness of risk
6. The significance of awareness of risk
7. Culpability beyond awareness of risk - some existing accounts
8. Negligence as failure of belief
9. Some practicalities.

Subject Areas: Criminology: legal aspects [LAR], Jurisprudence & philosophy of law [LAB]