Constitutional Stupidities, Constitutional Tragedies

William N. Eskridge (Edited by), Sanford V. Levinson (Edited by)

9780814751329

Paperback / softback, published 1 June 1998

296 pages
22.9 x 15.2 x 1.5 cm, 0.408 kg

""Identifying constitutional stupidity and constitutional tragedy form the flip-side, as it were, of deciding what is truly intelligent, praiseworthy, and valuable about the Constitution. Thus, exploring stupidities alleged to exist within the Constitution, and tragedies that might result from interpreting the Constitution, enable us to begin to formulate an agenda for improving the Constitution."" (R. B. Bernstein, H-Law)

The country's most esteemed constitutional commentators consider the Constitution's greatest flaws
The Constitution is the cornerstone of American government, hailed as one of the greatest contributions of the Western Enlightenment. While many seem content simply to celebrate it, those most familiar with the document invariably find it wanting in at least some aspects.
This unique volume brings together many of the country's most esteemed constitutional commentators and invites them to answer two questions: First, what is the stupidest provision of the Constitution? "Stupid" need not mean evil. Thus, a second, related question is whether the scholar-interpreter would be forced to reach truly evil results even if applying his or her own favored theory of constitutional interpretation.
The contributors include Lawrence Alexander, Akhil Reed Amar, Jack Balkin, Philip Bobbitt, Gerard Bradley, Rebecca Brown, Steven Calabresi, Lief Carter, Christopher Eisgruber, Lawrence Sager, Marie Failinger, Daniel Farber, James Fleming, Mark Graber, Stephen Griffin, Gary Jacobsohn, Randall Kennedy, Lewis LaRue, Theodore Lowi, Earl Maltz, Michael McConnell, Matthew Michael, Robert Nagel, Daniel Ortiz, Pamela Karlen, Michael Paulsen, Robert Post, Lucas Powe, Dorothy Roberts, Jeffrey Rosen, Frederick Schauer, Michael Seidman, Suzanna Sherry, David Strauss, Laurence Tribe, Mark Tushnet, and John Yoo.